Michigan City retained Economic Visions, TND Planning Group, and Urban Advisors to evaluate the economic development potential around three alternative commuter rail stations. The commuter line is required to make safety changes to its track, opening the opportunity to relocate the line and build a new station and with it transit oriented development. Our team was asked to comment on three alternative alignments and determine the potential economic impacts of each for the downtown. Our conclusions outlined the potential economic benefits of each location, while acknowledging the political and implementation constraints. This study succeeded in building consensus for choosing an alignment, and at the final presentation the regional rail authority publicly announced support for the recommended station area configuration and development.